Skip to content
REDSTICK⌕

Compare · job: structural analysis and design · stage: design and approvals

Structural analysis and design, side by side

Every tool on the record for structural analysis and design: 21 software tools, from Advance Design, ETABS, FRILO and IDEA StatiCa Beam onwards, in alphabetical order. 1 has a free plan. On the record so far, 9 are on sale in the UK and between them they are sold in 72 countries. 16 carry an assessment of where they fit on a job and the catch. Each was read at the maker's own source, most recently on 16 November 2026.

ComparingAll 21 toolsChoose which
Show
Scroll right for the rest
Fact
RS-R1933 · SaaS · GRAITECAdvance Design
RS-R980 · SaaS · Computers and Structures, Inc.ETABS
RS-R1848 · SaaS · ALLPLAN GmbH (FRILO Software)FRILO
RS-R1875 · SaaS · IDEA StatiCaIDEA StatiCa Beam
RS-R1876 · SaaS · IDEA StatiCaIDEA StatiCa Detail
RS-R1877 · SaaS · IDEA StatiCaIDEA StatiCa Member
RS-R2212 · SaaS · Computer System Technology (コンピュータシステム研究所, CST)KIZUKURI (きづくり)
RS-R1442 · SaaS · LIRALAND GroupLIRA-FEM
RS-R2179 · SaaS · OasysOasys ADC
RS-R2180 · SaaS · OasysOasys AdSec
RS-R2182 · SaaS · OasysOasys Compos
RS-R2187 · SaaS · OasysOasys GSA
RS-R2011 · SaaS · Structural PANDAPANDA
RS-R991 · SaaS · Dlubal SoftwareRFEM 6
RS-R993 · SaaS · AutodeskRobot Structural Analysis Professional
RS-R1838 · SaaS · Dlubal SoftwareRSTAB 9
RS-R1859 · SaaS · SchöckSchöck Scalix
RS-R994 · SaaS · SCIA (Nemetschek)SCIA Engineer
RS-R1468 · SaaS · SkyCivSkyCiv Retaining Wall
RS-R999 · SaaS · TrimbleTekla Structural Designer
RS-R1476 · SaaS · TrimbleTekla Tedds
At a glance
What it doesStructural FEM software: a 3D model, static, dynamic, seismic, pushover and buckling analysis, code checks and sizing of concrete, steel, timber, composite and masonry members to Eurocodes and North American codes, automatic wind, snow and seismic loads, and reports that update with the model. An AI assistant answers questions and runs configured workflows.Desktop software for analysing and designing building structures: frames, slabs and shear walls checked to US and international codes.Desktop software for structural engineers that designs and verifies single components: beams, columns, frames, FEM plates, roofs, connections, masonry, foundations, pit walls and soil mechanics, sold as editions of bundled programs, with a BIM Connector that turns IFC or SAF building models into analysis models for load transfer.Desktop software that designs and code checks concrete beams: reinforced, composite concrete to concrete, pretensioned and post tensioned. It handles tendon layout, prestress losses, construction stages and long term creep and shrinkage, and gives deflections, cross section, fire resistance and buckling checks, plus bridge load rating.Desktop software for the parts of a concrete structure where beam theory does not apply: deep beams, walls with openings, corbels, dapped ends, pile caps and anchorage zones, reinforced or prestressed. It draws the geometry from templates or DXF, places real reinforcement, and reports stresses, anchorage, crack widths and non linear deflection with a pass or fail.Desktop software that models a steel or concrete member or frame as a 3D shell model with its connections, runs non linear, buckling and imperfection analyses, and code checks it, so buckling lengths and connection stiffness need not be estimated. Covers girders, beams, columns, cold formed sections, frames, strengthening of existing members, and reinforced or prestressed concrete beams and columns.Desktop structural calculation software for timber houses: allowable stress design of post and beam (and, in a second edition, two by four) buildings up to three storeys, producing the calculation report for building approval and for seismic and housing grade applications.Analyses building and civil structures by finite elements, including seismic, dynamic and nonlinear analysis, and designs reinforced concrete and steel members, with add on modules for soil, masonry, fire resistance, progressive collapse and large panel buildings.Desktop software that designs reinforced concrete beams, slabs, columns and piles, works out moment and shear envelopes, and offers reinforcement layouts that meet the code.Desktop software that checks the strength and stresses of any reinforced concrete or composite cross section under combined bending and axial load, to a wide range of international codes.Desktop software that designs composite and non composite steel floor beams at construction and final stages, picks beam sizes and studs, and checks footfall vibration.Desktop structural analysis and design software that builds a finite element model of a building, bridge or complex structure, runs static, dynamic, nonlinear and vibration analyses, and checks concrete and steel to international codes.Scheme design software for structural engineers: from a rough brief it generates thousands of code compliant frame options, costs each and calculates its embodied carbon, and plots them so the team can pick the best.Desktop finite element software for analysing and designing structures from beams to shells, with add-on modules for each material.Desktop structural analysis software: model the frame, run static, dynamic and buckling analysis, and check members to code, round tripping with Revit.Desktop software for the 3D analysis and design of frame, beam and truss structures: member models with section and material libraries, linear, second order and large deformation analysis, load wizards from site location data, design add-ons per material, and a multi language calculation report.Browser based design software for Schöck's structural connection products: Isokorb thermal break connections for concrete balconies and parapets, and Stacon shear dowels for expansion joints, with dowel selection and site reinforcement optimisation.Desktop structural analysis and design software for frames, plates and shells in steel, concrete and timber, exchanging models with BIM tools.Models a concrete retaining wall in 2D or 3D in the browser and checks sliding, bearing and overturning to the ACI Reinforced Concrete Design Handbook, with a free calculator and a fuller version for subscribers.Structural design software where one model carries the analysis, steel and concrete design, and the calculation reports that update with it.Runs structural calculations from a library of ready made, multi material calculations (beams, columns, connections, foundations, retaining walls, frames, floors and roofs) and lays out calc packages with each step shown, inside its own app or Microsoft Word.
Who it's forStructural engineers designing buildings in concrete, steel, timber and composite.Structural engineers designing buildings.Structural engineers, geotechnical engineers and civil engineering practices doing component design and verification.Structural and bridge engineers and precast concrete fabricators designing prestressed or composite beams.Structural engineers designing concrete and precast elements, and precast fabricators.Structural engineers, steel fabricators and consultants checking critical or unusual members.Structural engineers, architects and house builders in Japan who calculate timber homes themselves.Structural engineers designing buildings and civil structures, particularly in seismic regions.Structural engineers doing everyday reinforced concrete design on buildings and foundations.Structural and geotechnical engineers checking concrete and composite sections in buildings, bridges and piles.Structural engineers designing steel and composite floors.Structural engineers designing buildings, bridges and specialist structures.Structural engineers and design teams at the early scheme stage of multi-storey buildings.Structural and civil engineers.Structural engineers.Structural engineers designing steel, timber and concrete frames, trusses and beam structures.Structural engineers and designers specifying Schöck balcony connections and joint dowels.Structural engineers.Structural and civil engineers designing concrete retaining walls.Structural design engineers working with architects and fabricators.Structural and civil engineers producing calculation packages.
The catchNo price published; packages and extensions are sold separately.An engineer's tool; price not on the page.Sold as monthly priced editions; the BIM Connector comes only in the Professional and Ultimate editions and exchanges models through IFC or SAF files rather than a direct link.Single members only, fed with loads from a global model; the pricing page is unclear on which plan includes it, and the design codes are not named on the page.Works element by element on 2D and 3D details, so it needs the forces from a global analysis; the page does not list the design codes it checks to.Meant for critical members rather than a whole building, so the global analysis still comes from another program; the pages read do not name the design codes it checks to.Built for Japanese timber design rules and approval paperwork; post and beam and two by four are separate editions.Higher analysis options sit in the dearer configurations, and many functions are paid add on modules.Windows desktop software for element by element design, not whole structure analysis; the price is not published.Windows desktop software; it checks sections, not whole structures; the price is not published.Desktop software; the price is not published.Windows desktop software; packages are tailored by Oasys and the price is not published.Early scheme stage only, not detailed design; prices are not published and a trial is by request.The main program is a purchase; design modules and service cost extra.An engineer's tool; the price is not shown on the page.A desktop program for member structures; design checks are separate add-ons, and the yearly service contract costs extra.Designs Schöck products only; balcony design so far covers Isokorb K, Q, QP and Z, with other applications still in the earlier desktop programs.Price through the webshop, not on the product page.At release the checks followed one US handbook (ACI SP-17); the full module needs a SkyCiv Professional subscription.Subscription price not on the page.Windows only, and the Word functions need a Microsoft Office licence. Sold as an annual named user subscription.
AssessmentReplaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. GRAITEC's Advance Design runs static, seismic, pushover and buckling analysis and sizes concrete, steel, timber and masonry to Eurocodes and North American codes, with an AI assistant; by quote. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.Replaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. ETABS analyses and designs building frames, slabs and shear walls to US and international codes. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.Replaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. FRILO designs single components, beams to pit walls and soil mechanics, with a BIM Connector from IFC or SAF in the top editions; from 244 EUR a month. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.Replaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. IDEA StatiCa Beam designs reinforced, composite and prestressed concrete beams through construction stages, creep and fire; in the $374 Complete plan, the pricing page unclear. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.Replaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. IDEA StatiCa Detail checks the concrete regions beam theory misses, deep beams, corbels, pile caps, with real reinforcement and crack widths; from $166 a month on the US e-shop. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.Replaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. IDEA StatiCa Member models a critical steel or concrete member with its connections as shells and checks buckling without estimated lengths; from $274 a month on the US e-shop. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.-To checkReplaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. LIRA-FEM analyses structures by finite elements, including seismic and nonlinear analysis, and designs concrete and steel members; from 2,800 EUR, with many functions as paid add on modules. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.-To check-To check-To check-To checkReplaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. Generates thousands of code compliant early stage frame options and plots cost against embodied carbon for each; no price published. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.Replaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. RFEM 6 is finite element analysis with a module per material, $5,320 plus a $900 yearly service contract. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.Replaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. Autodesk Robot runs static, dynamic and buckling analysis and code checks, round tripping with Revit. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.Replaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. Dlubal's RSTAB 9 analyses 3D frame, beam and truss structures with load wizards from site location data; 3,750 USD to buy plus a 670 USD yearly service, design checks as add-ons. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.Replaces waiting on the manufacturer's engineer, or drawing their system yourself. Free tools from the connection makers: design their balcony connector, column shoe or dowel and get the calculation for the file. Schöck Scalix designs Isokorb balcony thermal breaks and Stacon dowels in the browser; balconies cover four Isokorb types so far. The catch: each covers its own maker's products only.Replaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. SCIA Engineer analyses frames, plates and shells in steel, concrete and timber, linked to BIM tools. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.Replaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. SkyCiv Retaining Wall checks sliding, bearing and overturning for a concrete retaining wall in the browser; at release the checks followed one US handbook, with a free calculator. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.Replaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. Tekla Structural Designer carries analysis, steel and concrete design and the report in one model. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.Replaces the engineer's hand calcs and the separate model for every check. The engineer's own analysis tools: one model through analysis, member design and the calc report. Tekla Tedds runs structural calculations from a library of ready made calculations and lays out the calc package; Windows only, on an annual named user subscription. The catch: these are engineers' tools: the software checks the numbers you put in, it does not make the design safe.
Buying it
Sold in-To check-To check-To checkAlbania, Algeria, Armenia, Australia +67 moreAlbania, Algeria, Armenia, Australia +67 moreAlbania, Algeria, Armenia, Australia +67 more-To checkKazakhstan, UkraineCanada, Denmark, India, United KingdomCanada, Denmark, India, United KingdomCanada, Denmark, India, United KingdomCanada, Denmark, India, United Kingdom-To check-To check-To checkGermany, United StatesUnited Kingdom-To check-To check-To checkIreland, United Kingdom, United States
Price shapeBy quoteNot publishedSubscriptionSubscriptionSubscriptionSubscriptionNot publishedPurchaseNot publishedNot publishedNot publishedNot publishedNot publishedPurchaseSubscriptionPurchaseNot publishedSubscriptionSubscriptionSubscriptionSubscription
PriceBy quote from GRAITEC; free trial offered.-To checkEditions listed from 244 EUR a month (FRILO Professional, Ultimate, Geotechnics Ultimate) and from 215 EUR a month (Geotechnics Professional); free trial and student licence.In the Complete plan, $374 a month for one seat on the maker's US e-shop, by the maker's pricing FAQ; elsewhere by quote. 14 day free trial.From $166 a month for one seat (Detail plan, with Detail 2D, Detail 3D and Checkbot), or $374 a month in the Complete plan, on the maker's US e-shop; elsewhere by quote. 14 day free trial.From $274 a month for one seat (Steel plan, with Connection and Member), or $374 a month in the Complete plan, on the maker's US e-shop; elsewhere by quote. 14 day free trial.-To checkFrom 2,800 EUR (Standard) to 8,750 EUR (Full); add on modules extra.Price not published; trial or demonstration on request from Oasys.Price not published; trial or demonstration on request from Oasys.Price not published; trial or demonstration on request from Oasys.Price not published; trial or demonstration on request from Oasys.-To check$5,320 for the main program; 12 month service contract $900.Subscription or within the AEC Collection; amount not shown. 30 day trial.3,750 USD to buy the main program; yearly service contract 670 USD; rental for 1, 3 or 6 months and a 12 month subscription also offered. 90 day free trial.-To checkEditions and subscriptions via the maker's webshop; no prices on the page.Free calculator; full module with a SkyCiv Professional subscription.Subscription; prices not on the page. 30 day trial.Annual named user subscription; online purchase in the US, UK and Ireland, larger orders through sales.
Released-To check-To check-To check-To check-To check-To check-To check-To check-To check-To check-To check-To check-To check-To check-To check-To check-To check-To checkOct 2021-To check-To check
MakerGRAITECComputers and Structures, Inc. · United StatesALLPLAN GmbH (FRILO Software) · GermanyIDEA StatiCaIDEA StatiCaIDEA StatiCaComputer System Technology (コンピュータシステム研究所, CST) · JapanLIRALAND GroupOasysOasysOasysOasysStructural PANDADlubal Software · GermanyAutodesk · United StatesDlubal Software · GermanySchöckSCIA (Nemetschek)SkyCivTrimbleTrimble

Every tick links to where we read it. “Not published” means the maker doesn’t say, not that it can’t. A maker’s figure is the maker’s claim, read at its source; we have not measured it. They are in alphabetical order, never by who pays.